Product Review: Tom’s Whole Care Peppermint Toothpaste
It actually doesn’t taste like potpourri or camel butt. Imagine that. My husband still isn’t convinced it will work as well as the Colgate Total, our usual brand. Both claim to whiten, reduce tarter, & prevent cavities. Tom’s makes no gingivitis claims, as does Colgate, but I like to live dangerously. (FYI…if he ends up having a case of gingivitis at his next cleaning appointment I may need a place to crash for a few days.)
Price wise it is about the same…around $4.50 a tube. I switched the kids over to the Tom’s Mango awhile back and they seem content and still seem to have the power to bite one another at the speed of light. Packaging is a mixed thing. Tom’s comes in a paper box, as does Colgate. Tom’s tube, however, can be recycled with metals and Colgate cannot. But…the metal tubes seem to split…and have sharp edges when they do. Anyone else have this problem…or is it just me that lacks the skills and coordination to load a child’s toothbrush properly without severing a finger?

I started using this toothpaste two tubes ago, and I’ve been very happy with it. I haven’t had any trouble with the tube splitting yet, but I tend not to fold or roll the tube until I’m nearly finished with all the paste…
re: the gingivitis, that’s really a FLOSS issue more than a toothpaste issue according to my dentist. as long as everyone is flossing once a day you should be good!